Thursday, April 3, 2008

How does the open source community earn bread and butter ?

I always wonder, why the heck in this world do open source developers make their mehnat available to everyone. Microsoft might well be taking their ideas and selling on their own. Ya dude, but there's an honor code in the name of GNU public licence. Microsoft ... really ?

2 comments:

Siva said...

Hey. I was just surfing and found your blog. Hmm .. it is very obvious isn't it? How open source community makes money.

For instance RedHat makes money with their enterprise linux. (Service, maintanence, upgrades etc)

However the catch, open source "community" doesnt make any money. It's like asking how does IEEE make money. The research is free but there are always ways you can milk money out it. For instance, advertisement.

Anyway, going back to your question of GPL. Dude it's law and you can't break it even if you are Microsoft - they will simply close you down. But yes, you can use the ideas - and strictly not code - but then who cares. Concepts are always taken. Everyone knows how a bulb works, but not everyone can make it :) But that doesnt mean you can take a Phillips' bulb and re-package it and sell it as yours.

So the bottomline is, GPL is copyright. Just like any other company's copyright. You CAN NOT cross it. But it does give you a lot of freedon to learn and do the implementation on your own. Well, thats the whole point anyway, isn't it? To be Open :)

Siva said...

To add to my comment. You are confusing "Open Source" with "Open ideas". They are different. For instance you could have an open source implementation for a copyrighted idea (let's say google talk, mp3 codec, Java). Open source only talks about implementation. Ideas are pure research and can be patented / published somewhere else.